Serious Misconduct at Work: What It Means for Employees and Employers

Serious misconduct meeting

Serious misconduct (often called gross misconduct) is deliberate or wilful behaviour by an employee that is serious enough to make continuing the employment untenable. Under the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth), it includes theft, fraud, assault, sexual harassment, being intoxicated at work and refusing a lawful and reasonable direction. It also includes conduct that causes a serious and imminent risk to someone’s health and safety or to the employer’s business. But none of these are automatic.

When serious misconduct is established, an employer can dismiss an employee “without notice” which means they do not pay the notice set out under the NES or the employee’s employment contract. This is called summary dismissal. But calling something “serious misconduct” doesn’t automatically make a dismissal fair. The Fair Work Commission still looks at whether the conduct actually happened, whether dismissal was a proportionate response, and whether the employee had a genuine chance to respond.

Being accused of serious misconduct is stressful, and the next few days matter. If you need advice on your situation, call Fair Workplace Solutions on 1800 565 975.

What Counts as Serious Misconduct at Work?

Serious misconduct is defined in regulation 1.07 of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth). The term carries its everyday meaning, and the regulation spells out what it includes:

  • wilful or deliberate behaviour that is inconsistent with continuing the employment
  • conduct that causes a serious and imminent risk to the health or safety of a person
  • conduct that causes a serious and imminent risk to the reputation, viability or profitability of the employer’s business
  • theft, fraud, assault or sexual harassment in the course of employment
  • being intoxicated at work
  • refusing to carry out a lawful and reasonable instruction that is consistent with the employment contract

There’s an important catch. The regulation lists some specific examples: theft, fraud, assault, sexual harassment, intoxication and refusing an instruction. For these, the employee can argue the conduct wasn’t serious enough to justify skipping the notice period. Context still matters.

Is gross misconduct the same as serious misconduct?

In practice, yes. Australian law uses the term “serious misconduct”, and “gross misconduct” as a common informal name for the same thing. Whichever label an employer uses, the Fair Work Commission applies the same test.

Is it serious misconduct? Common examples

Behaviour Usually serious misconduct? What decides it
Theft, fraud or falsifying timesheets Often, yes Dishonesty goes to trust. Intent matters more than the dollar value, but context still counts.
Assault or physical violence Often, yes Listed in regulation 1.07. Provocation and self-defence are relevant.
Sexual harassment Often, yes Listed in regulation 1.07.
Being intoxicated at work It can be This is complex and should be advised by your employment lawyer as there are limits and nuances as to whether this would be considered serious.
Refusing a lawful and reasonable direction It can be The direction must be lawful, reasonable and within your role, and the refusal must be deliberate.
Serious safety breaches It can be For example, bypassing safety guards or lockout procedures in a way that creates a serious and imminent risk.
Bullying a colleague Depends Not on the regulation’s list. Sustained or severe bullying can be serious misconduct. A one-off incident may not be in some circumstances, however, it also can happen once and still be a terminable offence.
A heated argument or swearing at a manager Usually not on its own Workplace culture, provocation, whether threats were made and who saw it all matter.
Conduct outside work, such as social media posts or behaviour at a work function It can be There must be a real connection to the job, such as harm to the employer’s reputation, its business or colleagues.
Poor performance, mistakes or lateness No Not wilful. These are managed through feedback, warnings and a performance process.
Being off work on certified sick leave No The Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) protects a temporary absence for illness or injury that’s supported by evidence such as a medical certificate. Limits apply to unpaid absences longer than three months. A fake medical certificate is a different matter.

Three questions that help test the conduct

  1. Was it deliberate? An honest mistake, or one caused by a lack of training, is unlikely to be serious misconduct.
  2. Is it serious enough to break the relationship? The conduct has to go to the heart of the employment, such as trust, safety or the business’s reputation.
  3. Are there mitigating factors? Length of service, a clean record, provocation, health issues and whether others were treated differently for the same thing can all count. The Fair Work Commission regularly weighs these when deciding whether a dismissal was harsh.

Misconduct vs Serious Misconduct vs Poor Performance

Misconduct is a breach of the rules that’s usually dealt with by a warning. Serious misconduct is wilful or grave conduct that can justify dismissal without notice. Poor performance isn’t misconduct at all.

Poor performance Misconduct Serious misconduct
What it is Not meeting the standard of the role Breaking a rule or policy, without the gravity of serious misconduct Wilful or grave conduct that’s inconsistent with continuing the employment
Examples Missed targets, repeated errors Isolated lateness, minor policy breaches, unprofessional comments Theft, fraud, assault, sexual harassment, serious safety breaches
How it’s usually handled Feedback, training and a performance improvement plan. It can result in written warnings. Counselling and written warnings Investigation and possible summary dismissal
Notice if dismissed Yes Yes No notice or payment instead of notice

A pattern of ordinary misconduct can still give an employer a valid reason to dismiss with notice, usually after warnings. On its own, it still isn’t serious misconduct. And a zero-tolerance policy doesn’t turn a minor breach into serious misconduct. If you’re wondering whether you can be dismissed without a warning, our guide on whether you can be fired without warning covers that in more detail.

Can You Be Sacked on the Spot for Serious Misconduct?

No, you cannot be dismissed on the spot without investigation or consultation. Under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), the usual minimum notice rules don’t apply when an employee is dismissed for serious misconduct. That’s what “summary” or “instant” dismissal means. It is a concept that tricks most employers and leaves them vulnerable.

It doesn’t mean an employer can skip the process. If the dismissal is challenged, the Fair Work Commission will ask:

  • Was there a valid reason, based on evidence that the conduct actually happened?
  • Was the employee told the reason before the decision was made?
  • Did they get a genuine opportunity to respond?
  • Did the employer unreasonably refuse to let them have a support person?
  • Was dismissal proportionate, given their record and any mitigating factors?

Firing someone in the heat of the moment is risky. That’s true even when the conduct was serious.

What about small businesses?

Employers with fewer than 15 employees can rely on the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code. The rules are a little different. Under the Code, it’s fair to dismiss without following strict process when the employer believes on reasonable grounds that the employee’s conduct is serious enough to justify immediate dismissal. The Code gives theft, fraud, violence and serious breaches of safety procedures as examples. However, some sort of reasonable process must be undertaken the Employer cannot simply fire on the spot without talking to the employee. “Reasonable grounds” usually means the employer has made reasonable enquiries before acting, rather than relying on a rumour. Reporting theft, fraud or violence to the police can help the employer’s position, but the Code doesn’t require it. If the Code was followed, the dismissal is treated as fair.

By way of example, the employer took a look at the CCTV footage (eg. Investigated) and saw the employee stole something. The employer asked the employee about it (eg. Consulted) and the employee confessed. The employee was then dismissed. This is not a perfect process that will still have some hurdles to address at Fair Work but some semblance of a process was undertaken prior to dismissal.

How Should an Employer Handle a Serious Misconduct Allegation?

A sound process protects a summary dismissal. For employers, it’s the difference between a decision that stands and an expensive claim. For employees, knowing these steps helps you spot when a process has gone wrong.

  1. Respond to the incident without deciding the outcome. Where safety or the integrity of the investigation requires it, the employer may suspend the employee, usually on full pay. The suspension letter should make clear it isn’t a finding of guilt.
  2. Gather the evidence. CCTV, system logs, timesheets, emails and witness statements. The more serious the allegation, the stronger the evidence needs to be before a finding is made.
  3. Put the allegations in writing. Set out what’s alleged, when and where, and share the evidence relied on. This is often done through a show cause letter.
  4. Give the employee reasonable time to respond. How long depends on how complex the allegations are and how much material there is.
  5. Hold the response meeting. Don’t unreasonably refuse a request for a support person. Listen to the explanation and test it against the evidence.
  6. Adjourn before deciding. Check anything new the employee raised, review their history and weigh up mitigating factors. Announcing a decision in the response meeting suggests it was made beforehand.
  7. Confirm the outcome in writing and process final pay. The letter should state the findings, the reason for dismissal, the effective date and what will be paid.

Common employer mistakes

  • Deciding first, investigating second. Comments like “this meeting is just a formality” are hard to recover from.
  • Refusing a support person. The Fair Work Commission specifically considers this.
  • Attacking character instead of conduct. “The swipe card records don’t match your timeline” is evidence. “You’re a liar” isn’t.
  • Treating people inconsistently. If others did the same thing and kept their jobs, expect that to be raised.
  • Waiting too long. A long delay between finding out about the conduct and acting on it can undercut the argument that it was so serious it ended the relationship.
  • Putting the wrong label on it. Calling conduct “theft” or “serious misconduct” doesn’t make it so.

Case in point: the ladder that wasn’t stolen

In Davidson v Sydney Tools [2023] FWC 1980, a store employee was summarily dismissed for theft. He’d borrowed a ladder from the Gosford store on a Sunday. His daughter was locked out of her apartment. He returned it before opening the next morning. Sydney Tools dropped the theft allegation on the day of the hearing.

The Fair Work Commission accepted that taking stock without approval was a breach of policy and a valid reason. But it found the dismissal harsh and unreasonable, for three reasons:

  • it was a one-off error of judgment that warranted a warning
  • there was no dishonesty or financial loss
  • no proper investigation was carried out

He was awarded $19,401.75 in compensation, after a 10% reduction for his own misconduct.

Good process takes days, not hours. If you’re an employer facing a serious incident, our team can run or review the investigation and help you manage the termination meeting itself. See our workplace investigations service or call 1800 565 975.

What Final Pay Are You Owed?

Some of what you’re owed changes. Not all of it.

Entitlement Paid after dismissal for serious misconduct?
Wages for time already worked Yes
Accrued, untaken annual leave Yes
Notice or payment instead of notice No
Redundancy pay No, as it isn’t a redundancy
Long service leave Depends on your state or territory and your length of service

Long service leave is where serious misconduct can bite. In NSW, for example, an employee with between 5 and 10 years of service is generally entitled to a pro rata payment if dismissed. The exception is a dismissal for “serious and wilful misconduct”. Once you’ve reached 10 years, the accrued entitlement is generally payable regardless. Other states have their own rules.

Most modern awards require final pay within 7 days of the employment ending, and some set shorter deadlines. For a full breakdown, see our guide to final pay entitlements.

Is It Better to Resign or Be Dismissed for Serious Misconduct?

It depends on the strength of the evidence and what you want to protect. If the allegations are disputed or exaggerated, or the process has been handled badly, resigning usually works against you. It can cost you the right to bring an unfair dismissal claim. If the evidence against you is strong, a negotiated exit can sometimes protect your record. Either way, get advice first. A resignation is hard to take back.

Resigning Being dismissed Negotiated exit
Unfair dismissal claim Generally not available, unless you were forced to resign (constructive dismissal) Available if you’re eligible and lodge within 21 days Usually given up when you sign a deed of release (a settlement agreement)
Notice You give notice under your contract or award Not paid Often negotiated as part of the deal
Your employment record Shows a resignation, though the employer’s records may note an investigation was underway Shows a dismissal for misconduct Can include an agreed statement of service or reference
Annual leave Paid out Paid out Paid out

Resigned in the heat of the moment? It may not count. We acted in a Fair Work Commission case that clarified exactly this point. See our guide on whether you can claim unfair dismissal if you resign.

How to Respond to a Serious Misconduct Allegation (and What Not to Say to HR)

Stay calm. Be specific, and stick to the evidence. You’re trying to show one of three things:

  • the conduct didn’t happen the way it’s alleged
  • it wasn’t deliberate
  • dismissal would be out of proportion

What to say, and what to avoid

Instead of saying Try Why
“Everyone else does it too!” “I don’t believe this rule has been applied consistently, and I haven’t had training on it.” Points to inconsistent enforcement without admitting the conduct.
“This is a witch hunt!” “I’m concerned the outcome may have been decided before I’ve had a chance to respond.” Raises procedural fairness in terms the employer has to take seriously.
“Fine, I quit!” “I’d like some time to get advice before I respond.” Protects your options. Resigning can cost you an unfair dismissal claim.
“My boss is an idiot who provoked me.” “This happened after concerns I raised on [date] that weren’t addressed.” Puts provocation and context on the record without attacking anyone.
  • Called into a meeting without warning? It’s reasonable to ask for the allegations in writing and time to prepare.
  • Shown evidence you haven’t seen? Ask to review it properly before answering.
  • Told you’re being dismissed? You can say you disagree and that you’re reserving your rights. Then ask for the termination letter and final pay details in writing.

Your checklist

  • Write down a timeline of events, the names of anyone who saw what happened, and any positive reviews or feedback, while it’s fresh.
  • Don’t send company documents or client data to your personal email. That can create a fresh reason for dismissal.
  • Bring a support person to any meeting, and ask them to take notes.
  • Put your response in writing, even if you also respond in person.
  • Don’t post about your employer or the situation on social media.
  • Speak to an employment lawyer before you sign or agree to anything.

Can You Challenge a Summary Dismissal?

It can be worth it, especially if the evidence was thin, the response was out of proportion, or you weren’t given a fair chance to respond. Every case is different. Get advice early.

Most claims never reach a hearing. In the three months to September 2025, the Fair Work Commission finalised around 4,060 unfair dismissal matters. More than 9 in 10 ended without a decision being made, most commonly through settlement at conciliation or by the claim being withdrawn. Only 45 dismissals were formally found to be unfair.

Are you eligible to claim unfair dismissal?

  • Time limit: you must lodge your application with the Fair Work Commission within 21 days of the dismissal taking effect. Extensions are only granted in exceptional circumstances.
  • Minimum employment period: at least 6 months, or 12 months if your employer is a small business with fewer than 15 employees.
  • Income: you’re covered by a modern award or enterprise agreement, or you earn less than the high income threshold. For dismissals on or after 1 July 2026, that threshold is $190,100.

What can you get?

Reinstatement is the main remedy. Compensation is far more common. In July to September 2025, the Commission ordered compensation 31 times and reinstatement 12 times. Compensation is capped at the lower of 26 weeks’ pay or half the high income threshold, which is $95,050 for dismissals on or after 1 July 2026. The Fair Work Commission can reduce compensation where the employee’s own misconduct contributed to the decision to dismiss. That’s what happened in the Sydney Tools case above.

When general protections may apply instead

If the real reason for your dismissal was that you exercised a workplace right, you may have a general protections claim instead. Exercising a workplace right includes making a complaint, taking sick leave or raising a safety concern. A general protections claim also has a 21-day deadline, but it doesn’t have a minimum employment period or a high income threshold. If the matter goes to court, compensation isn’t capped the way it is for unfair dismissal.

Get Advice from an Employment Lawyer

Serious misconduct matters move fast. What you say or sign early on can shape everything that follows. Fair Workplace Solutions is a specialist employment law firm that works with both employees and employers across Australia. You’ll deal directly with one of our employment lawyers, like Shelly or Massi, not an HR adviser acting as a middleman. Most of our services are offered on a fixed fee, so you know the cost up front.

For employees, we can:

  • review the allegations and evidence
  • help you prepare your response
  • advise on whether to resign or negotiate an exit
  • act for you in an unfair dismissal or general protections claim

Read more about our unfair dismissal lawyers.

For employers, we can:

  • run an independent workplace investigation
  • prepare show cause and termination letters
  • help you manage the termination meeting
  • defend Fair Work Commission claims

Our team also speaks Farsi, Dari, Hindi and Serbian.

Call Us Now! 1800 565 975 or contact us today.

This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. Employment law is complex and outcomes depend on your individual circumstances, so please seek legal advice about your situation.